27 February 2004,
Didn't manage to get shortlisted in the final 4. But still at 5th place. Not bad. Good job, Johnny. :)
Commonwealth Essay Competition 2004
1. What are you most proud of EITHER in yourself or your family OR in your country?
With a dark crimson wall as backdrop, two shopping bags, and a lady dressed in emerald cheongsam carrying them � this is the cover page of Lonely Planet�s latest edition on Singapore. Do continue reading. Your mind will be painted with an image of a modern cosmopolitan city-state where pockets of lush greenery are found amidst towering skyscrapers. Tucked under these buildings, rustic charms can be found in rows of conserved shophouses, ironically hiding their antiquity. The warm and harmonious islanders of Chinese, Malay, Indian, and Eurasian race welcome the world with open arms.
Welcome to Singapore, my country.
I am proud of this over-achiever; her economic miracle retold in books, magazines and press across the world continuously. It spoke of an island once deemed too small and too deficient in resources to succeed as a prosperous independent nation. But she did, with spectacular growth rates that earned her a ranking among the top international financial hubs. Accolades, such as a place on the list of top three most competitive economies around the globe or the renowned Changi Airport being voted Top International Airport, are only physical reminders of the achievements this young independent nation has, more than what the world expected, attained.
Yet even if the buildings disappear one by one from the skyline, and the near immaculate score sheet we are so used to getting becomes blemished, the pride I have for Singapore will persist to burn brightly � because of her identity. This is what makes her the way she is. It is the light that warms and gives this otherwise cold and anonymous city a certain cachet other places lack. Similarly, a national identity gives us a mirror to see ourselves as a nation for it is the people who live here that shape her individuality; this will subsequently come round to reinforce fellow countrymen�s attachment to this island we call home.
For me, it is hard to ignore this sense of belonging, not because of a strong national identity, but rather the lack thereof with its apparently weak and self-contradictory nature.
History has lent itself to be the blueprint for man to identify with themselves and their nation. The rich and illustrious past of great countries not only serves to stir up the nationalistic pride of their people living in the present; they have engaged my countrymen, with envy and intrigue, but at the same time, evoked a sense of grudging disappointment for the few epic episodes our nation has to leave for the present.
We do not have such grand stories to boast for, or rather, this is alien to us, the post war generation who has grown up in the era of economic takeoff, infatuated over statistical triumphs Singapore has made on infrastructural progress. Few can remember the preceding prosperous 12th century sea town of Temasek in the Sri Vijaya Empire that left no elaborate monuments or significant artefacts today to tell us of their past. Neither has the mettle of our nation been tested in harsh challenges against mankind. For example, the only war not too distant from memory is the Second World War, which is remembered however as the sacrifice of a colony, not a nation, then dependent on the defence of foreign troops. To be fair, few significant locals did emerge from the war to tell their tales of loyalty, strength, wit, and faith that tided them over some of the darkest days in history. But post-independent records of economic progress became the people�s preoccupation, resulting in these events becoming obscure.
Time ticks continually though. If Singapore is a piece of clay, history is what has been moulded so far, but note: this process of shaping never stops. Many people have accused this thirty-nine year old nation for not having a true piece of history that can drum pride into their hearts but I think this often results in the purpose and significance of that short period being misplaced. After all, we are in the process of creating history every single day. Yet unlike other long established nations like Britain, France or Japan, everything for us has to begin almost from scratch.
Chapter One, a lyrical account of our physical improvements, is almost ending. I see it whenever I take time off the fast paced city lifestyle to look out of my window on the thirteenth storey, observing dawn falling upon the sprawling forest of apartments; and their canopies seem to grow taller every time I look as they compete for that very first ray of light. An occasional evening walk down the cradle of Singapore, the Singapore River, evokes nostalgia because on the placid river�s surface, the clear reflection of warehouses on the opposite bank adorned with flashing neon signboards frees my imagination. It flies back in time to capture the bustling sight of lighters and bare-chested coolies crowding there then. The place continues to be brimming with people today, but they are out to party in bars and lounges that have assumed these shells of warehouses. Behind this, the reflection of towers is cut at the waist by the river, prompting me to look up to the sky and at these amber-lit buildings.
I would often pause at this sight to think of how Singapore has defied expectations to realise this seemingly insurmountable feat but this scene of progress, prosperity and modernity only sets the stage for the longer stride to become a distinct city with her own culture. Therein lies Chapter Two, Three, Four and so on.
Singaporeans are often stumped when asked to identify what makes this country their home. Their intuition would prompt them to retaliate: families and friends; nevertheless, even this can be uprooted and moved to another place. They would then, out of nonplusses, fling out perhaps by far the most unique product of our evolving identity � food. What else, they must have thought, can be more colourful than the cuisine here? These dishes could already entice the appetites of foreigners and locals alike by their exotic names alone, taken from native languages and dialects, such as �Nasi Lemak� (an assortment of fried chicken wings, eggs, anchovies and rice cooked with coconut milk), �Char Kway Teow� (a blend of rice noodles and black soy sauce) and �Bubur Cha Cha� (an ensemble of yam and sweet potato in coconut milk).
Certainly though, Singapore is more than the food she has to offer. This elusive concept of national identity involves elements less tangible and material; it is about the spirit of this land and the traits of her inhabitants that add the vibrancy to this country. However, the lack of a common national history makes her poor to build a strong national identity, thus compelling us to look back at our past as an immigrant colony, a flourishing seaport and subsequently a fledgling nation, from the position of the present-day cosmopolitan city to search for possible answers to this perplexing question.
One discovery would be the racially diversified yet united society Singapore has established since her colony days, somewhat resembling a quilt sewn together with various pieces of cultures each belonging to an ethnic group. In an information age when, courtesy to technological advances, images of ethnic conflicts are beamed worldwide, we are fully exposed to the violent fights which obstinately ignore the suffering, in the name of them dying martyrs� deaths. It is painful to see children lose their innocence and future to become suicide bombers, human bullet shields, or violent demonstrators, when life is lived without security on a day-to-day basis.
Compared to that gloom, this island is emanating warmth and hope. It was a sight of camaraderie as my friends and I teased an Indian friend about her recent love for Bollywood movies at her house on Deepavali, the Indian Festival of Light over a traditional meal she had prepared. Similarly, I felt the close ties between Chinese and Malay teenagers on a rudimentary football field I saw along my walk home, from the uncontained joy their cheers announced with each goal their team shot in, or agonizing disappointment their drooping heads would silently convey when the football missed the net.
Nonetheless, Singapore may get entangled in the cobweb of ethnic troubles like Northern Ireland if we take this harmony for granted, as the government often reminds us, using the historical episode of the racial riot on 21 July 1964 that killed twenty-three people. This message is now enshrined in commemorations of that fateful day at all schools, which was passed on to students through carnivals filled with the usual rhetoric of food, costumes and accessories, with the hope that they would be able to appreciate our multi-cultural society more. Such an artificial approach naturally raises disagreement from some people who assert that instead of appreciation alone, it is the close bonds forged between different racial groups, given more opportunities to interact, that would strengthen the social fabric which is divided by colour, yet united by one heart.
These efforts may sound contrive but artificiality is undeniably part of our national identity. Being an island that lacks natural resources, we are not meant to survive, much less succeed as a nation. Singapore today is created out of shrewd policy planning and by the sheer will of our people who have seen these plans through to fruition. In spite of that, it is a harsh yet truthful reminder consistently forced into our minds that this sight might not be forevermore. Our prosperity is precarious. Hence, we cannot afford, as a small island-state, to isolate ourselves from the international community which we are so dependent on for survival and progress.
But looking at the conundrum in another way, it is also this nagging knowledge of our artificiality that acts as the fuel igniting us to strive forward as one. The affluent, demanding Singaporeans seem to be always armed with a long list of complaints. They would either be lamenting about the trappings, particularly the high costs, of being a resident here, blaming the paternalistic government for its overt presence in every facet of their lives, or finding fault with the stress wrought upon by the humdrum city life that has few entertainment outlets to offer.
All these grouses however will be unheard of in times of a national crisis, when �bite-the-bullet� measures would be taken swiftly with a chorus of public approval, as every person would put aside his personal reservations aside for the general good of the country. It has been repeatedly seen during the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis, the subsequent economic turmoil three years later and the recent outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS).
This kind of unity is what precisely strikes me as uniquely local. Though faced with the occasional unhappiness aroused by subjective imperfections existing in this society, like any other in the world, Singaporeans, who bear full understanding of their country�s vulnerable position, would join hands to put on a brave and relentless fight against any challenges standing in her way. Such support is seldom seen in other countries where the individual tends to come before the nation. Pragmatic, intelligent, efficient and effective � these characteristics of our people not only ensure the continuity of our success into the near future, they attribute to the resilience and strength of Singapore, empowering the majestic roar of the tenacious lion from the �red dot� on the world map to make himself heard in every corner of the world.
To end off, I leave with you a verse from a local poet, Edwin Thumboo, who succinctly describes every Singaporean�s dilemma: as we search for our identity to define a pressing future and a brief past, while living up to the ever-changing present. These challenges test our unity as one people, and reaffirm our identity as one nation � Singapore.
�Hunting for a future leaves memories and images
Of crucial moments: gritty challenges which, for some,
Are high despair and doubt; a time to think of leaving.
Stay and be damn�d, or prosper in our fashion.�
Word Count: 2000
3:49 pm