love actually, 2007
23 April 2006,

iconic eyesores

Was reading on Zaobao how Mr. Charles Landry, an international expert on city development has described Singaporean icons as �containers� without �content�.

In this desperate pursuit of transforming into a global creative city, part of our stakes is laid on building awe-inspiring places. I mean, if small Singapore can�t build the largest, the tallest, the widest, then surely we need some words to give that oomph factor into our new complexes � �iconic� is one of them.

In the near future, you will see Marina South littered with such buildings. Every new development claims they are coming up with iconic designs, every new design is hailed by the press as the symbol-to-be of this cosmopolitan city-state.

Yet, so what if you create something out of the world, scoring many firsts in technical and aesthetic design? A building, first and foremost, ought to be functional. That is the basis of judging if this development should go ahead or not.

Look at Montreal�s experience with their 1976 Olympic Stadium. They wanted to create an icon for the world to admire. But their space-age design was beleaguered with high costs and engineering problems that the futuristic stadium only serves as a reminder of the debt the city incurred.

A building needs to connect with the people it serves. Example: The Esplanade. It actively encourages a lively arts scene in the community, removing the barrier formed by its grandeur to welcome amateurs and small local arts groups to put on their acts in the centre.

It also hosts numerous free community events, bringing in Singaporeans from all walks of life. Such a dynamic relationship with the public is the reason why the Esplanade is a much beloved icon, rather than a stinking Durian eyesore initially thought to serve only the highbrow and rake in tourist dollars.

The same however cannot be said of the new Supreme Court building despite it being well-utilised. The view from the Padang � this spaceship-looking disc protruding out of the old Supreme Court turquoise classical dome shows the design�s failure to consider the surrounding heritage. In contrast, the modest new Parliament building settles snugly in the Civic District.

So what are icons exactly? Iconic need not necessarily equate to a great design (c.f. pre-911 NYC WTC), though some basic criteria have to be met, like a strategic spot, a good vantage point.

Eventually though, it�s determined by the relationship between the place and the people. Will it serve its intended purpose? And most importantly: Will it be something Singaporeans are proud to associate with? For you can set out to build an icon, but whether it is one or not lies ultimately in the opinions of the masses.

4:37 pm







eXTReMe Tracker